Incidentfirst seen 21 Nov, 11:18 UTC
How bad is the FBI cyber attack? What security people are saying
Security practitioners read the FBI cyber attack as tense (−24 on a scale from −100 to +100), across 36 posts from 33 distinct voices in the 6 hours since it was first seen.
- Security leaders
- no posts since it broke
- Security community
- −24
- 33 voices since it broke
−24
Tense
The mood and the volume since it broke
Each disc is a stretch of time. Its height is the mood, its size is how many posts; a stretch with fewer than ten posts is drawn as an outline on the line. The busiest hour began at 11:00 UTC on 21 Nov with 8 posts.
The same curve as a table, hour by hour
| Hour (UTC) | Posts | Mood |
|---|---|---|
| 21 Nov, 11:00 | 8 | too few to read |
| 21 Nov, 12:00 | 7 | too few to read |
| 21 Nov, 13:00 | 5 | too few to read |
| 21 Nov, 14:00 | 3 | too few to read |
| 21 Nov, 15:00 | 5 | too few to read |
| 21 Nov, 16:00 | 8 | too few to read |
What worries them
The share of the 33 voices who raised each worry. One dot is a tenth of them.
-
41%
Sensitive systems are not isolated from the internet
11 voices
-
15%
AI may be enabling more capable attacks
4 voices
-
11%
Cuts and firings weakened government security staffing
3 voices
What people said
12 short lines from public posts, each linked to the post itself. Nobody is named here.
-
Yes. Tell that to all the "air-gapped" systems I've seen over the years that were no longer air-gapped.
Community, on Hacker News, −50
-
I mean I think it's a double tap. Goofs in office + Automated AI bug finding and hacking.
Community, on Hacker News, 0
-
The fact that these systems are not air-gapped[1] is very troubling. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_gap_(networking)
Community, on Hacker News, −50
The facts
This sheet is the reaction, not the record. For what happened, read FBI reportedly investigating apparent hack of its criminal database (bbc.com).
Most of the posts counted here are on Hacker News.
How this is measured
Only posts about security count, each scored from −100 to +100, and no figure is printed from fewer than ten posts. How mood is measured